Best No Shock Dog Training Collar

5 Best No Shock Dog Training Collar Reviews in 2023

The pet industry in the last decade or so has been flooded with tons and tons of pet products purportedly to make our lives as pet owners easier and at the same time, improve the health and lives of our pets.

That is true and so it’s only natural that certain innovations wouldn’t sound as good in the ears of some pet owners like say, shock collars. We hear you, for those who can’t stand the thought of shocking their beloved pets even with a tiny bit of pulse then perhaps you may utilize a no shock dog training collar to improve undesirable behaviors. Read on!

What is a no shock dog training collar?

No shock dog training collars are devices that won’t have static shock stimulation as one of their behavior correction modes. This is a dog training collar that other dog owners deem shock collars to be a harsh way to deal with your dog’s behavior.

A no shock dog training collar employs multiple ways of stimulation like vibration or spray. And, it’s worth mentioning that there are a lot of other types of dog collars in the market aside from no shock and shock collars that you may choose from.

Are no shock dog training collars also an effective way for behavior correction of your dogs?

When it comes to effectiveness that would totally depend on the situation. First of all, shock collars aren’t as harsh as some would say they are, it’s actually the other way around.

Shock collars are not a form of punishment and on the contrary, it’s one effective way to correct your dog’s behavior and communicate with them. But there are just some owners who don’t like using them and they just go for no shock collars and that’s the avenue that we want to help out on in this article.

And for a good reason, you probably won’t need static shock stimulation for your dog. All you have to do is to gauge your dog’s recognition for stimulants and decide whether which type of dog training collar you’d need for the program.

5 Best No Shock Dog Training Collar Product Reviews

PetSafe Remote Spray Trainer

PetSafe Remote Spray Trainer - 3 in 1 Dog Training Solution

Key Features:

  • 3 training options.
  • 2 different scents.
  • 40-hour battery life.
  • 300-yard range.

If you’re looking for an effective way to curb your dog’s undesirable behaviors but don’t want to use any static shock stimulation then you need to start with the PetSafe Remote Spray Trainer.

These no shock training collars have got 3 effective training modes onboard, spray, vibrate, and tone. The spray options offer citronella and unscented sprays so your dog may be deterred before or during any mischievous behavior.

The vibration option is a perfect way to distract so they won’t chew, jump, dig, or bark excessively on impulse, and lastly, there is a highly audible tone that you may try out on the first part of your training.

This dog training collar is perfect for sensitive dogs but is proven to be not as effective to stubborn dogs so be sure to take note of that. We also appreciate how this collar is so well-rounded with other cool features.

The collar is waterproof and comes with a rechargeable battery that’s going to last for 40 hours. The cartridge will hold about 35 sprays so you’ll have a lot of juice when disciplining your dog whether outdoors or indoors. It’s easy to refill to boot.

This unit is effective within a 300-yard range so you may definitely get your dog to roam free and you can still communicate with them effectively.


  • Good battery quality.
  • Decent range.
  • Good value for money.
  • Durable collar.
  • Multiple effective stimulation options.


  • Not that ideal for very stubborn dogs.

Check Today’s Price Amazon

Paipaitek No Shock Dog Training Collar

Paipaitek No Shock Dog Training Collar

Key Features:

  • 1600 feet range.
  • Waterproof.
  • 10 levels of vibration.
  • 20 days battery life and rechargeable.

One of the most innovative no-shock training collars on our list is definitely the Paipaitek No Shock Dog Training Collar. If you look at its price, you’d never expect that it will come with the set of features that are on board with it.

Let’s just start with the 1600 feet range that should be more than most no-shock training collars in the market today. The unit is typically a vibration collar but it brings 10 different levels of stimulation with it giving you a chance to gauge which one works best for your dog. No one size fits all approach right here.

Also, this collar is made out of TPU material and is IPX7 waterproof and guaranteed durable. It’s actually perfect for dogs with hard hearing and dogs of all sizes. Puppies, older dogs, and adult dogs can all benefit from this collar.

And, with only about 2 hours of charging, this unit’s battery can go for about 20 days on the average frequency of usage. It’s also quite popular and enjoys high ratings online because it’s an excellent communication device for you and your dogs and that it’s very affordable.


  • Great value for money.
  • Effective vibration levels.
  • Good range.
  • Superb battery life and quality.
  • Easy to utilize.


  • Not the most durable collar.

Check Today’s Price Amazon

Paws Furlosophy No Shock Dog Collar

Paws Furlosophy No Shock Dog Collar

Key Features:

  • 650-yard range.
  • 16 levels of vibration.
  • 100% waterproof.
  • 2 collars at a time.

The Paws Furlosophy No Shock Dog Collar comes with a tone and vibration mode of stimulation for your dog and a third one that’s slightly unconventional, light. Usually, the third mode for dog training collars is the static shock mode but not with this one.

Both the vibration and light modes come with 16 adjustable levels so you may gauge your dog’s recognition. The unit is IPX7 waterproof so it’s definitely meant for dogs that love to go for a swim when outdoors and both the transmitter and its strap are pretty ergonomic.

The range of 650 yards should be more than enough for you to let your dog a bit out of your sight and still communicate effectively when in outdoor situations. You may control 2 collars at the same time too.

This unit though is meant for slightly larger dogs so it’s not meant for smaller dog breeds. It’s also important to take note that you can’t use this collar on any dog younger than 6 months.


  • Ruggedly made.
  • Built to last.
  • Great for outdoor settings.
  • A bit pricey but worth it.
  • Simple intuitive but feature-packed transmitter and collar.


  • Not a very versatile collar in terms of sizing and breed.

Check Today’s Price Amazon

WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training Collar

WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training Collar

Key Features:

  • IPX7 waterproof.
  • LCD backlit display.
  • 3 stimulation modes.
  • 660-yard range.

Another pretty rugged device on our list is the WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training Collar. It’s also made for slightly larger dogs with a no-shock approach to behavior correction that’s very effective if you ask us.

It’s durable, it’s made out of TPU, and it’s waterproof. Great for outdoor settings and tougher training sessions if needed or you can just let your pup roam around freely but still communicate effectively for up to 660 yards easily the longest range on our list.

It comes with a multifunction transmitter that is just as durable as the collar. With 3 working modes, tone, vibration, and light. It’s rechargeable and a no-guilt way to really shape up the attitude of your dog.


  • Very effective stimulation modes.
  • Consistent vibration system.
  • Long-range.
  • Rugged design and built to last.
  • Great value for money.


  • Once again, not very flexible in sizing and breed compatibility.

Check Today’s Price Amazon

PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar

PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar, No-Pull Dog Collar

Key Features:

  • Comes in 5 different sizing options.
  • Multiple color choices.
  • No-pull design.
  • Padded neoprene.

The last entry on our best no shock dog training collar does not use any stimulation modes at all. The PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar is a manual way to try and correct your dog’s behavior.

It’s got a comfortable fit and material that would surely not bother your dog at all when it’s time for a walk. No coughing nor choking will be involved with this one too as it is designed differently.

This collar allows a full range of motions for your dogs so they can still freely move but we make sure to teach them to control excessive instincts systematically. You will fully be in control without restricting your dog so much.


  • Comfortable dog leader.
  • Simple design but effective.
  • The vet and trainer recommended.
  • No choking whatsoever.
  • Durable for the price.


  • It May is not as effective as E-collars.

Check Today’s Price Amazon

Dog Training Collars Buyers Guide

In the multitude of choices nowadays, what makes a good dog training collar? Here are some of the aspects that you should take into consideration when buying a dog training collar.


Amongst all the technology that’s onboard a dog training collar something so straightforward as size is still the most important aspect of this product. How come?

Well, the size of the collar means comfort for your dog and it means that you may administer your stimulations effectively. The vibration of a no-shock collar won’t be as effective if the collar does not fit well. And, of course, if the collar is ill-fitting then your dog won’t be comfortable with it. It may even hurt them.

Lucky for us, most dog training collars come in adjustable sizing that fits a wide range of dog sizes and weights.


Nylon, polyester, metal, hemp, are only some of the materials that your dog training collars will be made of. Make sure to go for collars that are durable, waterproof, weatherproof, and of course, comfortable for your pet.

Take note, most especially for larger dogs that they’d be hyperactive so you need a collar that can keep up. The collar should also be tough enough to withstand outdoor elements especially that some dogs love to swim either on water or mud.

Stimulation Modes

With no shock collars, it doesn’t mean that you have limited stimulation modes for your correcting your dog’s behavior. You will still have access to a wide variety of approaches to train your dogs. Spray and vibration look to be a top choice. Look for more innovative collars.

Other Features

Look for dog training collars that come with ergonomic transmitters that are also made from tough and rugged material. Some will have LCD screens and easy-to-understand buttons. Make sure that your unit won’t do misfires as much as possible. Read the finer details for more features especially if you’re spending a significant amount of money on it.

Don’t just look at the brand and say, well okay, this works. Make sure to explore more as some underdog brands will have feature-packed models too.

Frequently Asked Questions

So which is better, no shock or with shock dog training collars? In which instances would you recommend the former over the latter and vice versa?

As you’ve read on our product reviews, no shock collars either use vibration or spray to deter or correct any undesirable dog behavior. These modes of correction stimulation are usually part of what a shock collar also has.

So having said that, there’s really no technical reason as to why you should not use one over the other. It’s also not a question of harming your dogs either but it’s like the owner’s prerogative.

Take note that a shock collar does not mean punishment, on the contrary, it’s meant to communicate with your dog effectively. So really, if you’re still not comfortable with using shock collars then you’d be better off then with no shock collars.

But sometimes, there are instances that your dog’s behavior would really get out of hand and you’re going to use a bit more intense methods like a shock collar. But before you do, read articles about the technology so you’d know what you’re going through, like this one. Or ask for your local pet trainer’s thoughts about it.

Are our dog training collars really safe and effective?

There are multiple types of dog training collars. Bark limiters, invisible fence systems, remote dog training collars, and no shock collars are just a few. Some will be more favorable than others so make sure to study them before taking your pick.

But yes, dog training collars are generally safe, and when it comes to their effectiveness that would depend on how you use it and if you’ve bought the right collar for your dog.

So are shock collars not harmful or painful? Nope, they aren’t. We assure you that the “shock” coming from these collars is just meant to get your pet’s attention. Not really enough to harm them in any way.

What are the signs that I may need to use a dog training collar for my dog’s behavior?

Dogs are typically playful and high-energy especially the young ones so we must know when to use a dog training collar or not. We understand that things can get subjective so it’s not farfetched to think that you may need to ask the opinions of the expert on this matter.

Typically dogs that bark excessively and are overly aggressive towards other pets, animals, or people are the ones that will need behavior correction through a dog training collar. Does your dog ignore you once you go outside and don’t listen to any of your commands at all once off-leash? Then maybe it’s time to employ the help of a dog training collar.

As to how old a dog can be before you can use a dog training collar? Well, probably around 3 months old. Some start them even younger if really needed. As they say, you need to start them young.

Any tips and advice on how to effectively use a dog training collar?

As mentioned, you need to start training them young while their behaviors are still easy to mold. Also, please do get the help of a professional trainer if you’re unsure how to administer training through a dog training collar.

Make sure to find the recognition level of your dog in terms of the stimulants. Don’t overwhelm them right away. Some dogs will recognize tone or slight vibration. Don’t jump to static shock stimulation right away. And most of all, make sure that they are safe and comfortable.

Final Thoughts

So the next time you face certain behavioral issues with your beloved pet dog that you think needs correction and you don’t want anything to do with shock collars, don’t forget that there are a lot of alternatives out there and most especially, no shock dog training collars.

Please do remember that if we correct our dog’s behavior even if we need to be strict at times, that doesn’t mean that we love them less. That only means that we care for their welfare and that we only want what’s best for them and what’s safe for them.

So make sure to grab one or two of these innovative collars and do enjoy your training time with your beloved pet canines.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *